England player ratings vs. Spain: Newcastle & Leeds stars shine in superb win

placeholder image
Getty Images

Rating every England player out of 10 after their brilliant 3-2 Nations League win against Spain in Madrid.

Can a Nations League win ever be described as historic? Or unforgettable? Debatable, perhaps, but if England’s 3-2 win over Spain were to have taken place in any other competition it would go down as one of their great results, and as one of their finest team performances. Context matters, of course, but this was one hell of a good day’s work.

England outplayed Spain until Elliot Anderson’s red card and then battled it out through a rearguard action which rivalled their work against Mexico in the World Cup. The result was a jubilant Thomas Tuchel, victory in their Group A pool, and a place in next year’s Nations League finals.

But who really impressed, and who was simply along for the ride? We’ve rated every England player out of 10 below after a magnificent night in Madrid.

Trafford shone as England’s defence held firm against Spain

England's defence celebrates after the final whistle in Madridplaceholder image
England's defence celebrates after the final whistle in Madrid | Getty Images

James Trafford – 9/10: Prior to Spain’s penalty, Trafford wasn’t called upon to make a single save – but once the shots started raining down on England’s goal, Trafford was simply magnificent. His six stops included two outstanding double saves, the latter of which equalled any piece of goalkeeping we’ve seen since Gordon Banks turned Péle’s header over the bar back in 1970, suggested that Jordan Pickford has a very serious problem on his hands.

Lewis Hall – 9: Hall didn’t quite win every single one of his one-on-one battles with Lamine Yamal (who does?) but the statisticians reckon that he did win seven out of nine, all while filling up the stats sheet with recoveries, clearances and interceptions. This was a defensive clinic from a left-back who wasn’t at his best against Croatia in the previous game – and Yamal ended up cutting a largely frustrated figure.

Jarell Quansah – 5: For the second consecutive match, Quansah made a bad mistake which led directly to a goal for the opposition, on this occasion the penalty which almost turned the game on its head. Replays seemed to suggest that he might have been fouled on this occasion, but the ball was only in harm’s way in the first place because of his misjudgement. It’s a shame, as he was otherwise very good and positioned himself exceptionally well to deal with a string of late Spanish attacks – but he always seems to make a mistake somewhere.

Ezri Konsa – 8: Restored to the starting line-up after injury, Konsa was excellent at the back and scarcely let anything past him all evening – and also scored England’s second with a thumping header after the Spanish marking collapsed from a corner. A timely reminder of his quality and consistency for England while the defence continues to come under scrutiny.

Ben White – 8: White’s selection, presumably a reflection of Tuchel’s concerns about Alexander-Arnold’s defending, was a slight surprise, but the Arsenal full-back capped a solid performance with a well-timed run and an excellent finish through Unai Simón’s legs for the third and final England goal. At the back he was reliable if not necessarily dominant, but the goal was certainly his main contribution and the primary reason for his high grade here.

Bellingham was brilliant – but Anderson’s error almost cost England

England's reigning Player of the Year was in fine form once moreplaceholder image
England's reigning Player of the Year was in fine form once more | Getty Images

Declan Rice – 7: Rice was curiously quiet on the defensive side of the ball and didn’t seem to get involved in too many tussles for possession, but he was typically creative with the ball at his feet – he directly generated three shooting chances, one of which was Konsa’s header from a pinpoint corner.

Elliot Anderson – 4: On the plus side, Anderson’s glorious long pass through to Harry Kane led directly to the opener. On the other hand, his decision to haul down Yamal at 3-0 up to get himself sent off and throw the result into doubt was uncharacteristically stupid, and could so easily have been very expensive. It’s hard to be kind about that particular challenge, but it was a rare aberration indeed.

Anthony Gordon – 5: Gordon worked himself to the bone down England’s left flank and actually ended up winning more one-on-one duels than Hall behind him – but the end product was absent and he was also culpable for Spain’s second goal, running into trouble and giving the ball away to create the chance for the counter-attack which led to Nico Williams’ strike.

Jude Bellingham – 8: Could (and perhaps should) have scored right at the start of the game when he forced a superb point-blank save from Simón, but made up for that in the second half with the superb angled pass into White which created the third and ultimately decisive goal. In between those two moments, Bellingham put in a massive shift to hassle and harry Spain’s midfield, winning 10 out of 11 one-on-ones, a frankly ridiculous stat for a theoretically attacking midfielder.

Morgan Rogers – 6: A blocked shot from close range turned out to be pretty much his only noteworthy contribution in the final third, but like Gordon and Bellingham his work rate in the high press made a difference. This wasn’t Rogers’ best performance, but he’s still done enough down the right to suggest that he’s a viable long-term alternative to the increasingly injured Bukayo Saka.

Harry Kane – 7: Another game, another goal, as the inevitable century inches closer. It was a typically emphatic penalty to open the scoring, and he came within centimetres of getting a goal inside 10 minutes with a 20-yard effort which scraped past the far post. His hold-up and link-up play was typically strong throughout, too.

Myles Lewis-Skelly (on for Kane 78’), Djed Spence (on for Bellingham 83’), Dominic Calvert-Lewin (on for Gordon 83’) & Dan Burn (on for White 89’) – N/A: For the second game in a row, Tuchel made his substitutions so late that it wouldn’t really be fair to hand out grades. None of those who came off the bench made any mistakes, nor had time to make especially telling contributions.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice