Tottenham could sign immensely hard-working star as ideal Pedro Porro replacement
Spurs have been linked with a South American full-back at the same time that Pedro Porro’s future is up in the air - coincidence, or a January deal in the making?
Recent speculation surrounding the future of Pedro Porro, who has allegedly started to malinger for a transfer away from Tottenham Hotspur despite signing a new long-term contract just a few short months ago, has put Spurs in a slightly uncomfortable position. They may not want to lose the Spaniard, but succession planning could become compulsory quite quickly if the stories prove to be true.


As it stands, rumours of interest in Porro from Real Madrid and Barcelona remain just that – unproven rumours – but the frequency with which they have cropped up in the gossip columns means that there is enough smoke floating around for fans to worry that there might also be fire.
It may not be a coincidence that the stories suggesting that Porro could push for an exit in the near future seem to have come about at the same time that Spurs have been linked with a rising star of South American football who could represent a long-term replacement: Palmeiras right-back Agustín Giay.
Spurs targeting Agustín Giay – reports


Even Sport Witness, who reported this week on Spurs’ alleged interest in Giay, admit that they’re uncertain as to whether the North London outfit are likely to bid for the 22-year-old Argentine. Much like the stories linking Porro with Spain’s biggest clubs, there is far more speculation floating around than verifiable fact.
The one certain fact in the story right now is that Giay has just signed a new five-year contract with Palmeiras, but according to some Brazilian media sources – including ESPN Brasil – that doesn’t mean that he isn’t available for sale. They suggest that the move was intended to increase the young full-backs transfer value ahead of a January transfer window in which Palmeiras anticipate sanctioning at least one big sale. Giay, it’s claimed, could be one of the candidates.
The alleged asking price is hefty for a young South American, and he’s expected to set any potential suitors back at least €20m (£16.6m) – a fee which reflects the fact that years of high-profile sales have put Palmeiras in an exceptionally strong financial position. They don’t need to sell on the cheap, and have made it clear in many cases that they won’t.
ESPN’s reporting suggests that most of the interest that Palmeiras have had in Giay so far has come from Italy – while they don’t name the clubs in question, Napoli are widely reported to be among the clubs who have made enquiries – and the links with Spurs come from less credible sources so far. It’s impossible to say, at this juncture, whether Roberto De Zerbi’s side might launch a bid this winter.
Porro’s situation (if indeed there is a situation at all) might inform the decision-making process, as will the size of their remaining transfer budget. Giay might not be all that expensive by Premier League standards, but Spurs still desperately need attacking reinforcements and those are likely to be the first priority. Giay, if he is a target at all, will likely be a lesser consideration.
In short, the reports suggesting that Spurs are among the clubs circling Giay are speculative at best, but make a certain degree of sense under the circumstances. It helps that he’s developing into a very fine player.
Why Agustín Giay is on the shortlists of teams in Europe


A regular starter for nearly five years now – first with San Lorenzo in his home country and then with Palmeiras since 2024 – Giay has developed into a very balanced full-back already and has earned seven senior caps for his country. This is a player who has proven himself over the course of a fairly long period of time despite his youth.
Giay is a more conservative full-back than a player like Porro, but still supports the attack well – he’s equally happy to attack his opposite number on the outside or inside and has even scored four goals during the 2026 season while hitting the channels between the full-back and centre-half. The issue is that he lacks the crossing quality to set up as many opportunities as he might like. He has just three assists in his entire senior career to date.
While he’s more of a supporting act in the final third than a player who generates chances by himself, he’s become far more impactful in his own half. A combination of excellent anticipation, physical strength and bravery has made him extremely tough to beat in one-on-one situations and he consistently recovers possession while dealing with dribblers trying to take the ball past him.
That capacity to stand strong against quick and skilful players – the Brasileirão has no shortage of tricksy wingers – is his strongest suit and the reason that teams like Napoli (and perhaps Spurs) appear to be keen. Giay has developed into a reliable, immensely hard-working full-back with few weaknesses which can be exploited.
Whether Spurs make a move is hard to say – the speculation surrounding his future is full of conjecture and half-baked rumours, and even if Spurs are concerned about Porro’s future and the need for another right-back, it’s likely that Roberto De Zerbi would prefer a more aggressive and attacking type of player to suit his system. But Giay’s situation is worth keeping an eye on, as is Spurs’ own situation at right-back if the biggest sides in Spain continue to make overtures towards Porro.
