The stats which suggest that James Trafford should be England’s new number one


James Trafford has been brilliant for Leeds and proved himself against Spain - will he take Jordan Pickford’s job as England’s number one?
In the eight years that have passed since Jordan Pickford first established himself as England’s number one at the 2018 World Cup, his place has gone unchallenged. Other goalkeepers have played occasional friendly matches or stood in for dead rubbers, but every time that Pickford has been available and the match has mattered, he’s been between the sticks. Until now.
James Trafford’s transfer to Leeds United this summer served to spotlight his talent and now a sensational second-half performance against Spain has created a clamour for him to start in the forthcoming Euro 2028 qualifying campaign – and, perhaps, beyond. But is truly time to take the job away from Pickford?
The stats which suggest that James Trafford should take Jordan Pickford’s England place


There has always been a subset of England’s fanbase who refuse to be convinced by Pickford, even after 94 caps and five major tournaments – always those ready to point out that he isn’t a truly world class goalkeeper even though he has won games for his country on a number of occasions.
Pickford may not be ‘world class’ by most definitions – the statistics back up the suggestion of a fine but perhaps not earth-shattering career at club level which places him in a tier below the very best – but he has been England’s very best for nearly a decade now. There is a good reason that only Peter Shilton has earned more caps in goal for the men’s team.
Pickford’s contributions have been immense – his heroics in the penalty shootout win over Colombia back in 2018 alone were arguably the only reason that Gareth Southgate was given enough time to change the narrative about English football at the international level and to lay the groundwork for future tournament runs – and any disputes about his place since his debut were rendered laughable by the paucity of consistent competition. That was before Trafford came along, though.
Since signing from Manchester City in a deal which could be worth as much as £45m, the 24-year-old has flourished. He leads the Premier League in save percentage and in the more telling (if rather wordy and nerdy) post-shot xG prevented statistic – a measure of how many goals he is estimated to have prevented based on the shots he’s faced which were actually on target. He actually has been world class since the summer, and now he’s doing it for England, too.
His domestic performances earned him three of the six starts available in the relatively low-pressure environment of the Nations League, and it was against Spain that he really started to shovel coal into the engine of his own hype train.
He made six saves in the second half as Spain laid siege to England’s goal in the aftermath of Elliot Anderson’s dismissal and Mikel Oyarzabal’s subsequent penalty, including two superb double saves – the second of which, first from Fermín López and then from Aymeric Laporte – was arguably the best piece of goalkeeping by an England player since Gordon Banks tipped Péle’s header over the bar back in 1970. Superlatives have flowed since the final whistle, and all of them have been earned.
Suddenly, Pickford has some very real competition, and Thomas Tuchel now has two questions to answer – firstly, whether Trafford really is the better goalkeeper, and secondly whether Pickford’s wealth of experience should count for enough to keep him in the number one jersey even if the answer to question one is ‘yes.’


The chart above compares Trafford and Pickford’s respective performances across a few key statistics since the summer in the Premier League. It’s a sample size of just 10 matches and arguably insufficient, but it makes a very straightforward point – right now, at least, Trafford is performing to an exceptionally high standard which Pickford isn’t reaching.
None of the numbers on Pickford’s side of the board are bad, by any stretch of the imagination. He has been typically solid for Everton and has enjoyed a blemish-free campaign to date. It’s just that Trafford has been even better in almost every department.
The Leeds goalkeeper seems to be a better shot-stopper, is more confident and effective outside of his penalty area, and both he and Pickford have provided a near-identical quality of distribution. If Trafford can keep this up over the four months which separate us from the first Euro 2028 qualifying matches – England’s next matches in any competition – then it will be hard to make a strong case to keep Pickford in his post.
Will Tuchel give Trafford the number one jersey in 2027?


Prior to the 3-2 win over Spain on Sunday evening, Tuchel told the press that Pickford was still his number one even though Trafford was getting the gloves in Madrid. Immediately after the match, however, his tune had changed, and instead he stated that “there is no number one.”
It’s probably not worth reading too deeply into the precise wording of Tuchel’s comment. He’s made ill-considered and instinctive statements before which he later had to roll back – his reference to Jude Bellingham’s “repulsive” behaviour in 2025 made it clear that Tuchel doesn’t always get his words quite right in his second language – and it’s unlikely that he will have made a definitive decision about his starting goalkeeper in four months’ time based on only half an hour of football. Before the penalty, after all, Trafford didn’t have a single save to make.
Trafford’s task now is to build on recent form and to prove that he really is that good, that he really can maintain a save percentage north of 80%, that his 90th-minute double stop was a matter of routine rather than a one-off piece of brilliance. Even if he does all of that, however, he isn’t guaranteed to ascend to become Tuchel’s first choice.
The key advantage that Pickford has is his wealth of experience. He’s been two major finals and made key saves in penalty shootouts when everything is on the line. He’s done it all, and mostly done it very well. In the pressure-cooker environment of a summer tournament, a lot of head coaches would pick the goalkeeper he knows, beyond doubt, that he can trust.
Except that Pickford’s reliability isn’t necessarily quite beyond doubt. He had several wobbles during the 2026 World Cup and conceded goals he could and should have saved against Croatia, the Democratic Republic of Congo and perhaps Norway, depending on how harsh of a reading one wishes to take of his misjudgement of Andreas Schjelderup’s somewhat fortuitous opening goal.
He was excellent against Mexico, at least, a testament to the fact that he tends to come good when he’s needed most, but he picked a spectacularly bad time to have his first slightly shaky tournament.
Tuchel will likely have those wobbles in his mind as he watched both Trafford and Pickford over the coming months. If Pickford provides his head coach with any further causes for doubt, then it could mean his demotion.
Trafford is making a very strong case to take Pickford’s place going forward, but his fine form at Leeds and now with the national team is still no more than a flash in the pan compared to Pickford’s career. The Everton man probably has the edge, just about, by virtue of the sheer depth of his CV. But Trafford is closing the ground at blistering speed. Don’t be surprised if he’s number one by the time the Three Lions play another meaningful match.
