How much every Everton player is worth according to FM27 - including £57m gem and 'not for sale' icon
How much every Everton player is worth on Football Manager 2027, ahead of the game’s November 10th full release
Everton’s stellar start to the 2026/27 season continued on Monday evening, as David Moyes’ side rounded off Gameweek 9 of the campaign with a 1-0 win away at Newcastle United. It was the Toffees’ second win at St. James’ Park in a matter of days, having already knocked the Magpies out of the Carabao Cup on their own turf earlier in the week.
The strong start to the season enjoyed by Everton is even more impressive when you consider how threadbare their squad currently is, following a poor summer transfer window and a disastrous Deadline Day that left Moyes with a skeleton crew of just 22 players at his disposal. Keeping up their fine form all season with such limited numbers will be a tall task to say the least.
Meanwhile, Football Manager 27 is set to fully launch next week, allowing players to step into the virtual hotseat of their chosen club and become fully involved in matters on and off the field. Thanks to an early access window, player have already had a spin on the new game, and we’ve had a look through the database to find out how much every Everton player is worth.
How much every Everton player is worth on FM27
Starting with goalkeepers, Jordan Pickford is the only player in Everton’s squad to boast the coveted ‘not for sale’ status. This means that however much you offer the club, they simply won’t let him go. Cup goalkeeper Mark Travers is available for £20m, Tom King a mere £70k, while 21-year-old Fraser Barnsley would cost just £45k.
Moving to the back line, Jarrad Branthwaite is the club’s most valuable defender, with FM27 rating him at £56m. This actually seems rather conservative, given that the club are actually thought to be holding out for at least £80m should they sell him next summer. Jake O’Brien comes in a close second, with a hefty £54m estimated maximum price tag.
Things take a rather sudden drop from there, with Vitalii Mykolenko coming in at £25m. He’s closely followed by summer signing Ainsley Maitland-Niles at £24m, while James Tarkowski is available for just £9.4m. Bottom of the pile is Michael Keane, who is priced at £8.6m due to his contract being set to run out at the end of the current season.
James Garner named Everton’s most valuable player
Moving up into midfield, James Garner has been named as Everton’s most valuable asset by FM27, who deem the ex-Man United star to be worth as much as £57m. Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall would bring in a not too shabby £49m, while Carlos Alcaraz has a top value of £39m which a surprise, given that his current contract will expire at the end of the season.
Harrison Armstrong’s value is another eyebrow raiser, with the 19-year-old prospect down for a mere £27m - £13m less than the £40m Everton almost sold him to Nottingham Forest for last summer. Brennan Johnson, who arrived as part of a swap deal in the last transfer window, could fetch as much as £32m should the Toffees decide to flip him.
Versatile German midfielder Merlin Rohl can be scooped up for £31m, while Christian Norgaard is a rather more reasonable £19m, with his contract set to expire in the summer of 2028. Tyler Dibling comes in at a hefty £57m, which isn’t surprising given his great potential, while new boy Tyrique George is valued at a mere £21m. The club’s one and only central striker, Thierno Barry, is estimated to be worth as much as £42m.